Blog
Fake Invoices
With the growing reliance on the e-invoicing system and the continuous development of digital inspection and electronic linking tools at the Egyptian Tax Authority, fictitious invoices have become a topic that warrants special attention from company owners—not only because they violate tax regulations, but also due to the severe financial and legal risks that may arise from them.
Some companies may resort to obtaining invoices from other companies in exchange for a percentage or commission to substantiate purchases or expenses that lack proper tax documentation, or to reduce their payable Value Added Tax (VAT). While this behavior may appear to some as a shortcut to lower tax burdens, it actually places the company in the face of risks far greater than the tax amount it attempted to save.
To understand the full dimensions of this issue, we must start with the reasons driving companies toward this behavior, explain how the tax authority views these transactions, and outline the resulting consequences.
First: What Is Meant by a Fictitious Invoice?
A fictitious invoice is an invoice issued to substantiate a commercial transaction that does not exist in reality, or to document a sale, purchase, or service that never occurred between the parties stated therein.
It may take several forms, including:
- Issuing a sales invoice without supplying actual goods or providing a real service.
- Obtaining an invoice from another company without any genuine commercial dealing with it.
- Issuing an invoice with a value that differs from the actual transaction amount to fabricate expenses or tax deduction rights.
- Using invoices issued by companies engaged in selling invoices in exchange for a commission or a percentage of the invoice value.
Here, a clear distinction must be drawn between a fictitious invoice and an invoice accompanying a real commercial transaction that merely lacks certain data or supporting documents. Each case has its own legal and tax treatment, and not every clerical error on an invoice can be considered a tax evasion crime. The decisive factor is the reality of the transaction and the ability to prove it, rather than merely possessing a document formatted as an invoice.
Second: Why Do Some Companies Resort to Fictitious Invoices?
In practice, several reasons drive certain business owners to seek invoices that do not correspond to real transactions, most notably:
1. Dealing with Suppliers Who Do Not Issue Tax Invoices
A company may purchase goods or obtain services from suppliers or individuals who do not issue electronic tax invoices. The business owner then faces a challenge in substantiating purchases and expenses, particularly when needing supporting documents for accounting records and tax returns. Rather than resolving the issue at its source, some resort to buying an invoice from another company to prove a transaction that the issuing company never actually executed. However, a supplier’s failure to issue a tax invoice does not grant the buyer the right to use an invoice issued by another supplier merely to document the expense.
2. Attempting to Reduce Value Added Tax (VAT)
This is one of the primary reasons companies purchase fictitious invoices. When output tax exceeds deductible input tax, the company owes a net VAT liability. Instead of accepting the payable tax based on genuine transactions, some businesses obtain invoices from other companies for a specific percentage of the invoice value. The goal is to include fabricated input tax in the tax return to narrow the gap between output and input tax, thereby reducing the amount due.
3. Attempting to Reduce Corporate Income Tax
Some companies use fictitious invoices to add non-existent expenses to their accounts to lower net accounting profit, thereby reducing taxable profits. In this case, the company has fabricated a cost it never actually incurred and used an unauthentic document to alter its financial and tax outcomes.
4. Dealing with Companies Specializing in Selling Invoices
There are cases where companies issue invoices to third parties without real commercial transactions in exchange for a commission or percentage of the invoice value. These entities may exploit their tax registration or enrollment in the e-invoicing portal to make the invoices appear more credible. However, the existence of a technically valid e-invoice does not necessarily mean the commercial transaction it represents is genuine—a fundamental point business owners must recognize.
Third: How Does the Tax Authority Handle Fictitious Invoices?
Dealing with fictitious invoices is no longer merely a matter of reviewing paper documents, especially with the implementation of e-filing, e-invoicing, and e-receipt systems. The Egyptian Tax Authority has explicitly announced that it tracks companies issuing invoices for fictitious transactions, as well as companies using these invoices to unlawfully deduct taxes. In an official statement dated August 31, 2024, the Head of the Tax Authority confirmed that the authority’s electronic systems can detect fictitious transactions and trace the entire chain of parties involved.
What Triggers Suspicion During a Tax Audit?
Examples of indicators that may prompt deeper inspection and verification include:
- Purchase invoices lacking documents confirming the receipt of goods or execution of services.
- Repeated dealings with companies whose registered business activities do not align with the recorded transactions.
- Large financial transactions without corresponding commercial or operational movement.
- Discrepancies between invoice details and contracts, purchase orders, or warehouse records.
- A recurring pattern of invoice issuance among a group of companies without sufficient evidence of genuine transactions.
These are audit indicators rather than standalone proof of a crime, as the circumstances and evidence of each transaction must be verified.
Fourth: What Are the Tax Risks Resulting from Using Fictitious Invoices?
The issue does not stop at detecting the invoice; it often extends to reassessing tax returns and revoking tax benefits the company attempted to claim:
- Disallowance of Input Tax Deduction: If a company uses an invoice lacking a corresponding real transaction to deduct VAT, that deduction may be rejected and the payable tax recalculated. Consequently, the company may be required to pay the tax it tried to reduce, in addition to statutory additional amounts.
- Exclusion of Non-Genuine Expenses: If an invoice is used to substantiate a cost or expense not actually incurred, that expense may be excluded when determining the taxable base, increasing taxable profits and triggering a recalculation of corporate income tax.
- Tax Variances and Additional Tax: Re-audits may uncover undeclared or unpaid tax differences, requiring the company to bear the principal tax due plus the legally prescribed additional tax, depending on the nature of the incident and the audited period.
- Impact on the Company’s Overall Tax Position: Discovering fictitious transactions can lead to reviewing other related transactions beyond the specific invoice under audit, and the audit scope may extend to other parties involved in issuing or using the invoice. This results in additional time, costs, and instability in the company’s tax standing.
Fifth: Does Liability Fall Only on the Company That Issued the Invoice?
No. This is one of the most critical points company owners must understand. A business owner might assume that obtaining an electronic invoice from another company places full responsibility solely on the issuing party.
However, Value Added Tax Law No. 67 of 2016 explicitly addresses this scenario. Article 68, Item 10, classifies issuing invoices to third parties without underlying real sales operations as tax evasion and establishes joint liability between the invoice issuer and the beneficiary. Consequently, a company that obtains and uses an invoice without a genuine transaction bears legal liability, even if it did not issue the invoice.
What About Criminal Penalties?
Pursuant to Article 67 of the Value Added Tax Law, the crime of tax evasion stipulated therein is punishable by:
- Imprisonment from three to five years, and/or
- A fine ranging from EGP 5,000 to EGP 50,000, without prejudice to any severer penalty stipulated under another law.
- Doubling of the penalty if the offense is repeated within three years.
- Tax evasion under this law is classified as a crime involving moral turpitude and breach of trust.
Legal Note: The penalty mentioned pertains specifically to the cited provision in the VAT Law and does not mean that every invoice error or missing document automatically triggers tax evasion penalties; rather, it depends on establishing the legal elements of the violation or crime, the circumstances of the incident, and applicable laws.
Sixth: Can Fictitious Invoices Be Detected Despite Being Issued Electronically?
Yes. A common misconception is assuming that once an invoice is issued through the e-invoicing system, it is immune to suspicion or rejection during an audit. A clear distinction must be made between two matters:
- Technical Validity of Electronic Issuance: Fulfilling technical issuance and portal registration requirements.
- Commercial Validity of the Transaction: The actual occurrence of a real sale, purchase, or service between the parties.
An invoice may exist within the electronic system without representing a genuine commercial operation. As the Tax Authority has confirmed, its electronic systems allow it to trace fictitious transactions and the chain of linked parties, taking legal action against both issuing and benefiting companies. Possessing an e-invoice alone is therefore insufficient to prove transaction validity.
Seventh: What Should a Company Do If a Supplier Does Not Issue a Tax Invoice?
Since uninvoiced purchases are often where fictitious invoice cases originate, they must be addressed through sound legal and accounting solutions. When purchasing goods or services from a supplier that does not issue tax invoices, the company should take the following steps:
- Verify the Supplier’s Tax Status: Confirm the nature of the supplier’s activity, tax registration status, and whether they are legally obligated to issue electronic tax invoices under applicable rules.
- Retain Documents Proving the Real Transaction: Such as:
- Contracts and purchase orders.
- Proof of bank transfers and payments.
- Delivery and receipt notes.
- Warehouse records and inventory movement logs.
- Evidence confirming service delivery and acceptance.
- Determine the Proper Tax Treatment: Distinguish between substantiating an expense for accounting purposes, qualifying as a tax-deductible expense for income tax, and meeting eligibility criteria for input VAT deduction, as each is governed by specific conditions and documentation rules.
- Never Use an Invoice from Another Company: A gap in supplier documentation must never be resolved by obtaining an invoice from a company that did not execute the transaction, as doing so turns a documentation issue into a severe risk involving fabricated transactions and unlawful tax claims. Notably, the Tax Authority has announced that only electronic invoices are recognized for substantiating costs and expenses in corporate income tax returns, as well as for deducting or refunding VAT, effective from the announced mandatory implementation dates, subject to applicable scope, rules, and exceptions.
Eighth: How to Protect Your Company from Fictitious Invoice Risks
Protection is not limited to avoiding the purchase of invoices; it requires an internal control system that ensures transaction integrity from the outset. Key recommended measures include:
| Action | Objective |
| Supplier Verification | Confirm the supplier’s identity and active tax registration status. |
| Invoice Review | Verify the accuracy of invoice data and underlying transactions. |
| Document Matching | Link each invoice to its contract, delivery proof, and payment record. |
| Input Tax Review | Confirm statutory eligibility for VAT deduction before filing. |
| Tax Return Review | Ensure consistency between reported figures, ledgers, and supporting documents. |
| Periodic Internal Audits | Detect compliance risks proactively prior to an official tax audit. |
It is also advisable to conduct periodic reviews of past transactions, particularly if the company previously dealt with suppliers offering invoices for a commission without supplying actual goods or services.
Ninth: What If a Company Discovers It Has Already Used Fictitious Invoices?
In such cases, the company must not ignore the issue or continue carrying the same invoices forward in subsequent tax returns. The best course of action is to initiate a comprehensive review through a qualified tax and legal specialist, covering:
- Identifying the questionable invoices and the tax periods associated with them.
- Verifying whether genuine underlying transactions exist.
- Assessing the impact of those invoices on Corporate Income Tax and VAT.
- Reviewing previously submitted tax returns.
- Evaluating available legal and tax procedures to rectify the company’s position.
Management should not assume that merely paying the tax difference or amending the return automatically terminates criminal liability; reconciliation and its legal consequences are governed by specific statutory conditions and procedures, requiring an independent evaluation of each case.
Conclusion: Is Reducing Taxes Worth the Risk?
The situation often begins with a supplier who does not issue a tax invoice, or a desire to reduce VAT or corporate income tax. Obtaining an invoice for a percentage or commission may seem like a quick fix to lower tax obligations. However, once it is discovered that the invoice does not correspond to a real transaction, that step escalates into tax reassessments, additional financial claims, and legal proceedings that may reach the Public Prosecution and criminal courts.
The real issue is not the face value of the purchased invoice, but the liability incurred by using it. Sound tax management relies not on seeking documents that lower taxes on paper, but on structuring genuine transactions, documenting them properly, and applying accurate tax treatments.
How Can EGY Auditors Help You?
At EGYAuditors, we help companies manage their tax risks through a comprehensive suite of services, including:
- Reviewing the company’s overall tax standing.
- Auditing invoices, supporting documents, and commercial transactions.
- Reviewing Value Added Tax (VAT) and Corporate Income Tax filings.
- Assessing supplier compliance and vendor risks.
- Reviewing tax returns to identify potential exposure points.
- Providing tax advisory and assisting with tax audits and disputes in accordance with legal regulations.
Do not wait until an invoice turns into a tax crisis. Contact the EGY Auditors team today to review your company’s position and assess potential tax risks.